There are writers whodisown entire books after they ’ve save them , but sometimes writers like their account on the whole , but feel a twinge of regret over one a small ( or not - so - low ) detail . Here are a few decisions that the writer , in hindsight , wished they had thought through a little good .
https://gizmodo.com/10-great-authors-who-disowned-their-own-books-1571934580
plunderer for various stories ahead .
1 . J.K. Rowling : Hermione and Ron ’s marriage . Fans who were a bit perplexed that Hermione Granger ended up marrying Ron Weasley get a turn of exoneration whenRowling let out back in Februarythat the pair were n’t a plausible couple . The Sunday Times reported :
“ I wrote the Hermione / Ron relationship as a form of wishing fulfillment , ” she admitted . “ That ’s how it was conceived , really . For reason that have very little to do with literature and far more to do with me clinging to the plot as I first imagined it , Hermione ended up with Ron . ”
She sound on to say Harry would have been a better match . Rowling has also say that , after kill all those characters in all of those books , there is one minor character that she regrets marking for destruction .
https://gizmodo.com/the-one-character-jk-rowling-regrets-killing-its-not-wh-1671742588
2 . George R.R. Martin : Tyrion ’s aerobatics in A Game of Thrones . When Tyrion visits Winterfell , he has a physical artistry we do n’t in the later books . The former Tyrion jumps from a in high spirits logic gate , somersaulting to the ground , and it ’s one of the few parts of his expansive books that Martin repent . In a 2012 interview , Martin explain :
Ahm … await … What would I like to exchange ? Well , I might care to exchange the prospect where Tyrion Lannister is first introduce ; the setting where Tyrion jump from the top of a logic gate ; it is n’t possible . By then I had very few references about people of his condition and it was later when I total to know more drawn-out details about his forcible challenges . So that ’s one of the things I would change
3 . Alan Moore : Paralyzing Barbara Gordon in The Killing Joke . The Killing Joke is a comic that still makes a lot of fans of the Barbara Gordon ’s Batgirl cringe . The Joker shoots Barbara Gordon , damage her spur , not because she ’s Batgirl , but because she ’s the girl of Commissioner Gordon , whom the Joker is hoping to drive mad .
Moore has repudiated his DC work , and The Killing Joke is no exception , but he has specifically say that he went too far with Barbara Gordon ’s injury . The most lurid interview he ’s open on the matter is in2006 with Wizard Magazine , where he revealed just how his editor give him the greenlight :
I asked DC if they had any problem with me incapacitating Barbara Gordon – who was Batgirl at the time – and if I recall , I talk to Len Wein , who was our editor program on the project … [ He ] said , ‘ Yeah , okay , cripple the bitch . ’ It was probably one of the areas where they should ’ve rein me in , but they did n’t .
Later writers have been able to make lemonade from narration stinker , however , transforming Barbara Gordon into Oracle .
4 . Robert Kirkman : Cutting of Rick ’s bridge player in The walk Dead comedian . Okay , it ’s not on the nose a sorrow , since Kirkman tell he would n’t go back and commute it if he could , but he has read that , as cool a moment as it was , ingest the Governor cut off Rick ’s hand in the comics has become a bit of a pebble in his shoe . After all , now he has to figure out how Rick perform pocket-size tasks like buttoning his shirt or open a can . Kirkman has admitted that he did n’t think through the consequences of cutting off Rick ’s hand .
Kirkman has said thatit ’s mulct in the comics because it ’s a stable culture medium , but he thinksthe TV Rick should keep his hand .
Kirkman does have professional regrets that he would prefer to change . For one affair , he regrets killing off Marvel ’s Freedom Ring , at one point saying :
If I had it to do all over again … I would n’t kill him . I rue it more and more as time croak on . I got rid of what?[sic ] 20 % of the homophile characters at Marvel by killing off this ONE character . I just never took that material into condition while I was write .
And , although he did n’t write the episode , he also rue the revelations that total outthe CDC instalment ofThe Walking Dead . He felt that it reach too much away about the state of the world .
https://gizmodo.com/robert-kirkmans-one-big-regret-of-the-walking-dead-tv-s-1664617629
5 . J.R.R. Tolkien : Calling any of his graphic symbol “ Elves . ” It ’s hardly a surprisal that the linguist Tolkien has a regret that ’s less about story than semantics . But Tolkien was concerned not just with how the story appeared in his own head , but also how it look in readers ’ mind . One of the problems , Tolkien feel , was with the Elves .
When Tolkien called one of his wash “ Elves , ” he was not thinking of small , thin , power point - eared mass of contemporary folklore , but of tall , fabled beings . In a 1954 letter to Hugh Brogan ( number Letter 151 ) , Tolkien writes :
Also , I now deeply repent having used Elves , though this is a word in filiation and original meaning desirable enough . But the black adulteration of this Bible , in which Shakespeare played an unforgiveable part , has really overcharge it with regrettable step , which are too much to overcome .
Tolkien would sometimes rewrite his book of account for later editions . Most famously , he rewrote the “ conundrum in the Dark ” chapter of The Hobbit so that Gollum would be more aggressive , as he had been misdirect by the One Ring . He also changed the word “ Gnomes ” in The Hobbit , which he earlier used to refer to certain gremlin , but which he felt was mistranslated in readers ’ minds . The word “ Elf ” and “ extremely low frequency ” ride out , however .
6 . Douglas Adams : Killing everyone off in Mostly Harmless . The fifth Holy Writ in the Hitchhiker ’s Guide to the Galaxy serial publication has a major downer ending when the major fibre are brought to Earth just in time for the planet to be destroy by the Vogons . Adams later decided this ending was far too depressing , the result of a bad class on his part , and announced that he had plans to loosen it . In a 1988 interview with Matt Newsome , Adams say :
People have say , quite rightly , that Mostly Harmless is a very bleak book . I would love to stop Hitchhiker on a slightly more upbeat note , so five seems to be a wrong kind of number ; six is a better kind of figure .
Adams did n’t get to finish that 6th book , so Eoin Colfer undid the Mostly Harmless ending in his own Hitchhiker ’s book , And Another affair …
7 . J. Michael Straczynski : Making Norman Osborn the father of Gwen Stacy ’s children . If you call back that Sins Past , the storey that reveals that Gwen Stacy fell in love with Norman Osborn and bore him twins , was out of left frakking field , you ’re not alone . Straczynski himself claims that he hated the idea of Norman and Gwen having kids , and has said that he only went along with the idea because he thought he could retcon it away :
I wanted to retcon the Gwen twins out of continuity , which was something I always assumed I could do at the end of my discharge . I was n’t allowed to do this , and yes , it pissed me off .
He hoped that he could undo during the One More Day arc . Butwhat if Norman Osborn did n’t want that particular retcon ?
https://gizmodo.com/11-fan-theories-that-are-better-than-the-actual-story-1668825424
8 . Vince Gilligan : kill the Lone Gunmen on The X - Files . It somehow seems fitting that one of Vince Gilligan ’s big rue from The X - Files comes from an episode titled “ Jump the Shark . ” After The Lone Gunmen spinoff show was cancelled , Fox refuse to let the confederacy - loving trio back on The X - Files . So writers Gilligan , John Shiban , and Frank Spotnitz ended up killing them off . fan were overwrought , and in the end , the writers were n’t thrilled with the decision either .
InThe Complete X - Files , Gilligan told Chris Knowles and Matt Hurwitz , “ I still guess we made the unseasonable choice on that one . ” Spotnitz was a bit softer on the decision , saying :
I ca n’t say I rue kill them off , as you have sex , no one really dies in The X - Files [ … ] But I do feel tonally it was a mistake to end the episode on such a somber note . I wish we ’d ended it on a laugh or smile .
9 . David Lynch and Mark Frost : reveal Laura Palmer ’s killer in Twin Peaks . This is another decision that came not from the creators themselves , but in part because of web pressures . David Lynch in reality did n’t want to work Laura Palmer ’s murder at all , leave it as a yarn throughout the entire series ( though he did say that peradventure they could reveal the manslayer in the final episode ) . Mark Frost , however , feel they had an obligation to their audience to eventually solve the crime .
finally , they cave to web pressures to reveal the killer , but the show went off the rails for the writers without a likewise impactful moment in the second season . Lynch always maintain that solving the criminal offense so betimes in the series was a mistake , and Frost eventually amount around more to Lynch ’s line of thinking , saying decades later :
I had to kind of forge a compromise [ between Lynch and the connection ] . I ’m not certain that David was n’t correct . Maybe we should n’t have solved the secret . permit it drift on into the background signal and churn up more incidents as you run frontward .
10 . Sam Raimi : The tree ravishment in The Evil Dead . It ’s one of those scene that multitude single out , and commonly not in a favorable way . “ This is a great picture show … except for that tree rape conniption . ” And while some witness have defended the consequence , and find it entertaining , director and writer Sam Raimi ultimately regrets include it .
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vSMmWMIxUCE
I think it was unnecessarily gratuitous and a niggling too beastly . And at last because people were offended in a direction that I didn’t … my end is not to offend people . It is to entertain , thrill , panic attack … make them laugh but not to offend them .
Of course , Raimi would rework the movie with Evil Dead II . Then again , Raimi says that if he go back and reconstruct any of his film , he would do everything otherwise .
Harry Potterjrr tolkienLord of the RingsTwin PeaksWalking DeadX - data file
Daily Newsletter
Get the best technical school , science , and culture news in your inbox daily .
News from the future , delivered to your present tense .
Please select your desire newssheet and submit your electronic mail to upgrade your inbox .
You May Also Like
